

Newest Review: ... herself to sympathise to fully Hindley; this explanation without empathy. The book takes a traditional chronological approach to Hindley'... more
An Interesting But Missed Opportunity To Look At England's Icon Of Evil
One of Your Own: The Life and Death of Myra Hindley - Carol Ann Lee

Member Name: Emma4444
Product:
One of Your Own: The Life and Death of Myra Hindley - Carol Ann Lee
Date: 24/04/12
Rating:
Advantages: A well researched and written biogrpahy that doesn't sensationalise her crimes.
Disadvantages: There's no new revelations fact wise or in regards to Hindely's character.
The risk that books like these take is that the author will allow sick fascination with the crimes to overshadow their own moral repugnance and sympathy with the victim. That hasn't happened here. Nor has the author allowed herself to sympathise to fully Hindley; this explanation without empathy. The book takes a traditional chronological approach to Hindley's life and deals with everything from her childhood to her eventual death in prison. While impeccably researched, One Of Your Own does feel superficial at times. So much of Hindley's life has passed into myth that a simple recounting of the facts doesn't feel enough; the book leaves you wanting an explanation, a deeper understanding of her character. It also misses chances to illuminate the situation. We hear about Brady and Hindley's contrasting stories as to how the children were murdered but are never told of forensic evidence that would back either of them up. It doesn't really address Hindley's place in the pantheon of horrors and doesn't give the reader enough information to judge for themselves. Ultimately while an interesting read, the book fails to add much to what anyone interested in the Moors Murders would already know.
Summary: A good overview of Hindley's life in one volume, but nothing you couldn't get from the papers.
More reviews in the field of Biography
- They tried and failed to save Amy sadly
- Rockstars, Rockettes and Rockbottom
- Another formulaic soul searching novel for the fortysomethings.
- Nice!
- An Inspiration
- Case Closed? Not a Chance
- With my permish you'll get a comish!
- The life and times with a delinquent dog
- Likeable Linda
- An Entertaining read about entertaining films
- Into That Darkness: From Mercy Killing to Mass Murder - Gitta Sereny
- Like A Virgin: Secrets They Won't Teach You at Business School - Sir Richard Bra ...
- I Feel Bad About My Neck: And Other Thoughts On Being a Woman - Nora Ephron
- It's All News to Me - Jeremy Vine
- Woody Allen a Biography - Lee. Guthrie
- Going Rogue: An American Life - Sarah Palin
- The Litvinenko File - Martin Sixsmith
- Or Is That Just Me? - Richard Hammond
- Rollergirl: Totally True Tales from the Track - Melissa Joulwan
- Sid Vicious: No One Is Innocent - Alan Parker


