Newest Review: ... of the indomitable village that defies their rule. So, anyway, forget all about Asterix and the Big Fight. The only part of Asterix an... more
Charms and Changelings
Asterix Operation Getafix
Member Name: Jake Speed
Asterix Operation Getafix
Advantages: Some nice colourful film panels
Disadvantages: It's a bit rubbish and headache inducing
The only part of Asterix and the Big Fight they pilfer is Getafix the venerable druid accidentally being conked on the head by one of Obelix's menhirs and duly going bonkers. Menhirs are big Stonehenge style rocks made and sold by Obelix that seem to serve no purpose whatsoever and allowed Goscinny to riff on the absurdities of the capitalist system where people are constantly craving and purchasing things they don't really need. Now that Getafix is doolally it means he can't brew the super strength magic potion that enables the little Gaul village by the sea we know so well to resist Roman occupation. Without the magic potion Asterix and his village will be ripe for the plucking. The main story here is then plundered from Asterix and the Soothsayer - one of the best of the official Asterix books and a personal favourite of mine. It's a dark stormy night with spectacular crackles of lightning illuminating the little village with its cosy thatched huts and if the Gauls fear one thing and one thing only it's the prospect of the sky falling on their heads one day. They really don't like storms at all. An opportunistic and dubious Soothsayer named Prolix arrives in the village looking like a refugee from a 1960s open air rock concert and takes full advantage of the superstitious Gauls (who are sans druid less we forget as Getafix would see through him in a second) but he's soon kidnapped by the Romans. The Romans erroneously believe him to be a genuine Soothsayer and order him to drive the Gauls from their village so they can finally claim it for themselves. As ever it will be primarily up to the crafty Asterix to somehow make sense of this complete muddle.
So Operation Getafix is an abstraction and probably won't have a huge amount of appeal for those familiar with the bona fide series although children would probably enjoy the colourful panels I think. I haven't seen the film version of this but they seem to have made a number of changes and effectively dumbed down the books they are borrowing from. In Goscinny & Uderzo's Asterix and the Soothsayer, Prolix uses fish entrails to "read" the future but here he uses the fish as a glove puppet. It's not very funny and a good example of the sort of change they've gone for. There seem to to be pop culture references to things like The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy and Spielberg's E.T and characters here go mad and run around like lunatics at the drop of a hat. The subtext and nuance of Goscinny is buried underneath a very broad approach. The official Asterix books have a lot of jokes and references for adults (what other comic would reference The Anatomy Lesson of Dr Tulp by Rembrandt or the Peasant Wedding Feast by Pieter Breugel the Elder?) but they really don't seem to have bothered with that angle for this film at all. I suppose the animated film was necessarily broader than the Goscinny & Uderzo albums and much of this was lost. Some of the cells are very pretty - especially those that include the sun or the moon - but the problem is that they lack the detail of the original books and are a trifle fuzzy and lightweight on the whole.
Some of the characters don't quite look right either. Cacofonix the bard is a bit weird here and involved in some bizarre psychedelic panels. I think the animated films amp up the slapstick element to the Asterix series to a preposterous degree if Operation Getafix is anything to go by. It's rather headache inducing in the end and somewhat reminiscent of Uderzo's last couple of solo efforts where he didn't have the late Goscinny to do the writing and just genuinely seemed to lose the plot altogether, the books becoming increasingly frantic and juvenile rather than relying on the strength of the characters they had created all those years ago. The slapstick was turned up to eleven. I don't mind a surreal element to the books but by the end of this I did feel like I was being repeatedly hit over the head by a clown in a parallel dimension. I think Asterix fans and collectors would enjoy having these on the bookshelf purely for completist purposes but you woudn't imagine they'd return to this too much - if at all. Younger readers who aren't terribly familiar with Asterix that much and have nothing to compare this too or complain about might possibly enjoy it for the whacky colour strewn approach but that's about it really. I can't say the idea of watching the film version of this is very appealing after trawling through Operation Getafix.
Although I enjoyed the technicolour madness of some of the panels this always felt like a poor substitute for the official Asterix books and - like Asterix versus Caesar - this is hardly essential and more in line with Tintin and the Lake of Sharks. A book of a non-canonical film that you could happily live without. At the time of writing curious Asterix fans can buy a used copy of Operation Getafix for a few pounds. You might want to consider one of the Asterix compilations as this features in a couple of them and they are usually available at modest prices.
- Mazeworld (2000 AD) - Alan Grant
- James Bond: Polestar - Ian Fleming
- Superman / Aliens - Dan Jurgens
- Marvel Universe Avengers: Earth's Mightiest Heroes - Marvel Comics
- Green Lantern: Secret Origin - Geoff Johns
- Bleach 58 - Tite Kubo
- Batman Volume 2: The City of Owls TP (The New 52) - Greg Capullo
- Batman Dark Knight Returns TP - Frank Miller
- Batman Bat-signal - Running Press
- Attack on Titan 8 - Hajime Isayama