Newest Review: ... books, so that I can see what the finished result is supposed to look like. The book is divided into the following sections; Introdu... more
too sweet, sweet!
Cupcakes From the Primrose Bakery - Martha Swift
Member Name: europe-chick
Cupcakes From the Primrose Bakery - Martha Swift
Advantages: lovely coffee table book
Disadvantages: recipes are far too sweet, quantities are not accurate
I've had 'Cupcakes from the Primrose Bakery' for a couple of years now. I picked it up in one of those discount book shops - The Works I think, for just £2.99. I have the hardback copy and the full retail price of the hardback is £14.99, so I got myself a bargain.
Cupcakes from the Primrose Bakery was first published in 2009, and it's written by Martha Swift and Lisa Thomas, the founders/owners of The Primrose Bakery in Primrose Hill London.
I'd had my eye on this on and off for a while to add to my vast cookbook collection, and so when I spotted it for just £2.99 I immediately snapped it up, especially as it was the hardback version, I always prefer to get the hardback copies of cookbooks as I think they turn out to be much more durable than the softback copies. When I also spotted a quote from Nigella Lawson on the front cover ''this is an utterly enchanting book'', this cemented the fact that I had to have it, as I'm a huge fan of Nigella's cookbooks. However I should have actually paid much more attention to a little cartoon drawing of a bird on the front cover saying ''sweet! sweet!'', as this is what most of the recipes are in this book - (too) sweet, sweet. In fact they are way too sweet even for me, and I've got a real sweet tooth, just reading some of the recipes actually makes my teeth teeth hurt as there's that much sugar in them.
It is a lovely hardback book full of, as the title would suggest, cupcakes, with some layer cakes in the final chapter. The book is very beautifully presented and is lovely to just leaf through and browse. It's quite a substantial and heavy book, and the pages are thick high quality paper, with a slightly glossy finish to them. Each double page spread contains the recipe on one page and a full page colour photograph of the finished cupcakes on the other page. I always prefer to buy cookbooks that have photographs accompanying the recipes, especially cupcakes or baking books, so that I can see what the finished result is supposed to look like.
The book is divided into the following sections; Introduction, Basic Cupcakes, Basic Icings, Festive and Seasonal, Special Occasions, Weddings, Beyond Cupcakes, Decorations, Techniques and Equipment, Index, and Stockists.
The Basic Cupcakes section literally just has 4 basic cupcake sponge recipes, which are then used and adapted throughout the book. Vanilla cupcakes, chocolate cupcakes, lemon cupcakes, and carrot cupcakes. I can honestly say that the chocolate cupcakes recipe is anything but basic, it's the most convoluted chocolate cupcake recipe I've ever made, it takes forever and you seem to use every bowl you have. Everything needs beating or whipping separately, I have a freestanding Kitchen Aid mixer and so I really only have one bowl to whisk in so to speak, so I couldn't beat the butter and sugar in one bowl, and then whisk the egg whites in another, and then they also recommend that you beat the egg yolks separately with an electric whisk too! I've made the chocolate cupcakes just the once, it took me forever, and they really were not anything special after all that effort.
All of the basics cupcakes recipes are sweeter than normal, not excessively so at this stage, but certainly sweeter than most other cookbooks recipes. One other thing to mention here is that the quantities that the recipes state that they will make are way off. I've got at least another 50% out of all of the recipes that I've tried, so if the recipe states that it will 12 cupcakes, I've easily made 18, and sometimes even up to 24 cupcakes.
The Basic Icings section shows you how to ice your cupcakes using a palette knife as opposed to using an icing bag and piping the frosting on top. This takes quite a bit of practice, and even then they never look as good as the photos in the book. I also find that by icing cupcakes this way that you end up with much more frosting on the cupcakes than you actually need or want, especially when you see just how sweet the icing recipes in this book are! This section just has half a dozen basic icing recipes, and again they are used and adapted throughout the book. Vanilla buttercream, chocolate buttercream, lemon buttercream, coffee buttercream, orange cream cheese icing, and lime & coconut buttercream.
Just to give you an example of how sweet the frostings are; the vanilla buttercream icing contains a whopping 500g of icing sugar to just 110g of butter. I was always taught growing up to just double the quantity of icing sugar to butter for buttercream, so in this instance I would have used just 220g of icing sugar with the 110g of butter, and even that is bordering on the slightly too sweet side for me. I've made quite a few of the different frostings, and I've never once used the full amount of sugar, there's no way at all that they need it, even reducing the amount of sugar most of the frostings are still way too sweet. The frosting recipes also have the same problem as the cupcake recipes; they are way off quantity wise. I can easily frost double the quantity of cupcakes that the recipe tells me I'll be able to.
The Festive and Seasonal section contains seasonal cupcakes, and cupcakes for celebrations and special days. This is the largest section of the book, and the section where you'll see scrummy (looking) cupcakes, and get ideas and inspiration from if you do find the recipes to be too sweet as I do. It has cupcakes for new year, valentine's day, mother's day, easter, father's day, july 4th, summer, halloween, winter, and christmas.
The Special Occasions section is quite disappointing as it doesn't actually have any new recipes, just half a dozen very basic, and very boring cupcake decorating ideas.
The Weddings section only contains one actual recipe; white amaretto cupcakes with amaretto buttercream icing. It concentrates really on icing and displaying cupcake tiers for a Wedding. I have made these cupcakes, although I have adapted the recipe to make them less sweet. The cupcakes themselves are sweet, but not too sweet, however the recipe calls for an amaretto flavoured sugar syrup to then be poured over the tops of the cupcakes whilst they're still warm, sheesh what's with the sugar overload in this book! I omit the sugar syrup part, they definitely do not need any extra sugar. I also adapt the amaretto buttercream icing recipe and I use much less icing sugar than is stated!
The Beyond Cupcakes sections contains a small selection of layer cakes; chocolate layer cake, vanilla layer cake, coffee & walnut layer cake, and lemon layer cake. Once again all very, very sweet though.
The ideas in this book are fab, and some of the flavour combinations are delicious, however the main problem is that all of the cupcakes and the icings are sweet, with the majority actually being way too sweet. Another big problem is that the quantities are not accurate. I find myself having to adapt most of the recipes to use less sugar, and to make fewer cupcakes or less frosting. My copy has loads of post its stuck all over it with my adaptions that work and that I'm happy with.
Most of the recipes are easy enough to follow and to make, with the odd exception that's a bit more complicated. I don't actually think the cupcakes I've made have been outstanding, just good enough really. On the whole I think that the cupcakes are nicer than the frostings in this book, and a lot of the time I just choose to use a cupcake recipe and then frost it with one of my own frosting recipes
I find that I use the recipes, and the photographs, just as inspiration and a staring point most of the time and then I adapt them to suit my needs or tastes, head off on my own tangent. The photographs are stunning and they do actually inspire you to create your own little masterpieces. It is a lovely book to leaf through and dip in and out of, but maybe that's what it's best for just leafing through!
Summary: too sweet, sweet!
- The Smitten Kitchen Cookbook - Deb Perelman
- The Medicinal Chef: Eat Your Way to Better Health - Dale Pinnock
- The Fabulous Baker Brothers: Glorious British Grub - Tom Herbert
- The Green Kitchen: Delicious and Healthy Vegetarian Recipes for Every Day - Davi ...
- Wahaca - Mexican Food at Home - Thomasina Miers
- Fast Cakes - Mary Berry
- Eat Cuban - Judy Bastyra
- Bruschetta: Crostini and Other Italian Snacks - Maxine Clark
- Favourite Sweets and Toffee Recipes: Traditional Home-Made Confectionery - Carol ...
- The Abel & Cole Cookbook - Keith Abel