Home > Speakers Corner > Discussion > Referees - incompetent or just followling orders?

 Referees - incompetent or just followling orders? Discussion

Referees - incompetent or just followling orders?

 
Description: Sports: Football / The referee is assisted by two assistant referees (formerly known as linesmen), and in some matches ... more
Referees - incompetent or just followling orders? ... also by a fourth official. The match officials utilise a positioning system known as the diagonal system of control. The referee's powers and duties are described by Law 5 of the Laws of the Game.

Newest Review: ... him off, one yellow then the second yellow where the player should have been sent off and the third yellow which eventually led to the player being sent off. I have refereed games before and even without checking you know who you have booked, if Mr. Poll was not sure why didn’t he check his notes, it takes 5 seconds and nobody is going to notice, that’s just sheer incompetence. Let’s also ... more

 ... look at the Chelsea Liverpool game in the champions league in 2005, was the ball over the line, I don’t think with all the video technology now we even know, but how can the linesman know 45 yards away, the answer to that is he cant, so why give the go...more

kristian1111
Premium Review Referees - incompetent or just followling orders?: Men in black, i think they have the harder job than Will Smi ... (902 words)
by kristian1111 - written on 08.02.07 (Very useful, 61 readings)
Rating:

As with all of my case studies I am going to give a yes section and a no section to my debate then make my own mind up based on how I can convince myself, by the way I don’t have a split personality I just like to argue with myself! Yes Referees are incompetent, lets look at the facts referees seem to get at least one big decision wrong a game, was it a penalty, was it over the line, surely anybody can see this but somehow the referee’s for one reason or another get it wrong. Each match has one ref and two assistants and a forth official, so between one of them they should be able to get the decision right, my argument is why don’t the ...

sympatic
Premium Review Have you ever met your Dad? (393 words)
by sympatic - written on 11.02.06 (Very useful, 71 readings)
Rating:

The man in the middle has a pretty tough job and to be honest the assistant ref has an equally tough time of it with the confusion over the changes to the offside rule. Having umpired hockey matches before I know just how hard it is to watch the flow of play and be able to monitor whether a player is in an offside position and to be honest half the time I would say that I was guessing. Thankfully now the sport has got rid of the offside rule and it is one less thing to worry about. One of the main things that makes a referee life tough is the attitude of the players, football is unique as a sport that seems to allow verbal abuse of the officials, ...

utero
Premium Review Referees - incompetent or just followling orders?: Are You Blind Ref! (511 words)
by utero - written on 10.07.03 (Very useful, 49 readings)
Rating:

There's just over four weeks to go until the football season starts again, thank god because I've been going cold turkey not having any football on the TV and no excitement over who's doing what. Footballs certainly got a bit more popular in recent years. Yes it's always been popular in this country but now after a little bit of a dip the game is taking off again even though the money is going down. Not only are there sell out crowds in the Premiership but the Nationwide Leagues have been enjoyed increased gates over the last season. When it comes to matters on the pitch there is one man who stand between two teams. This is the man that ...

 
dooyoo
Guided TourCommunityRegisterLoginHelp
Top