Home > dooyoo Lounge > Discussion >

Should the House of Lords be abolished?


 Should the House of Lords be abolished? Discussion

Should the House of Lords be abolished?

 
Description: The Lords rejection of the Bill banning hunting with hounds has led to renewed calls for the abolition of the second ... more
Should the House of Lords be abolished? ... House. Is Britain truly a democracy, with unelected peers able to veto the decisions of democratically elected MPs? Or is it a necessary balance to the power of career politicians from the Commons? Let us know whether or not you think the House of Lords should be abolished here.

Newest Review: ... put the figures at a rough guess at about 20% against, 20% For and around 60% indifferent who have not really thought about it. Therefore a second house that can consider items raised and can look at their impact upon this country without so much political thought is surely a good thing. YES I understand about the problems of unelected peers being able to veto decisions and also the issue ... more

 ... of heriditary peers are two crucial thoughts in regards to the House of Lords. Lets think about the issue of Heriditary peers first. I personally think that this is in parts possibly a better idea than peers which have been given a peerage by polit...more

jpegington
Premium Review Should the House of Lords be abolished?: NO - Keep the House of Lords (415 words)
by - written on 05/05/07 (Useful, 575 readings)
Rating:

The House of Lords is in my opinion a necessary tool that is a very useful counterpart to the House of Commons. Take into account the issue mentioned above in regards to the House of Lords: The issue of Fox Hunting and other measures that the Labour party has pushed through the House of Commons due to their large majority can only be stopped by a second house that is independent and not politically motivated. Bear in mind that not all of the UK is against Fox Hunting (in actual fact I would put the figures at a rough guess at about 20% against, 20% For and around 60% indifferent who have not really thought about it. Therefore a second house that can ...  Read the complete review

paul36
Premium Review MP's more corrupt than the Lords (259 words)
by - written on 05/05/07 (Useful, 165 readings)
Rating:

House of Lords is a select group of people who keep an eye on the laws made by MP's. Lords also called Peers have to pass a bill before it becomes law. Currently there are 751 peers. 26 are Lords Spirituals 725 Lords Temporal Spiritual Lords: 2 archbishops, 24 bishops. Temporal Lords: 633 Life peers (made by government), 90 hereditary Peers and two ministers of Crown. History of Lords goes back centuries. Once Lords had more powers than Parliament. Slowly Parliament has increased its power since it is selected by the common people. I don't want the house to be abolished because it protects the rights of us ...  Read the complete review

flyingsparks
Crowned Review Should the House of Lords be abolished?: Time for a total change - Let's see some real democracy (927 words)
by - written on 05/05/07 (Very useful, 312 readings)
Rating:

When considering the possible abolition of the House of Lords there are several aspects of the question to consider. 1. Does the British parliamentary system, of which the House of Lords is a part, operate as effectively as possible for the benefit of the British people? 2. Would the abolition of the House of Lords improve parliamentary system? To answer the first question, Does our present parliamentary system, and the House of Lords in particular operate as effectively as possible, I believe that this question must be answered with a 'No', the main reason for that is because the parliament we have at the moment is a mess. It ...  Read the complete review

Poor_student
Premium Review Keep the Lords and get rid of the likes of Tony Blair! (911 words)
by - written on 06/06/06 (Very useful, 1207 readings)
Rating:

The talk of getting rid of the House of Lords raises one question: what would replace it? I would like to raise the consequences of getting shot of the Lords, but first, describe a little bit about the Lords. PS. If a cetain university lecturer is reading this, it is my work (an abridged version from one of my essays previously submitted) and so it's not plagiarism! The Lords is the supreme court in the country, and also the second chamber in the political system. It consists of approximately 700 members, 92 of which are hereditary. Lords are not elected as members of the Commons are, but are appointed on recommendation of selection committees. ...  Read the complete review

fuzzybear
Premium Review Should the House of Lords be abolished?: A place to have a nap (392 words)
by - written on 23/03/06 (Useful, 261 readings)
Rating:

Although the political system is based upon a two chamber legislature with the monarch providing the third level of checks and balances in the system as the Queen has to sign all bits of legislation, in effect this signing of legislation is a formality, whilst the second chamber the House of Lords actually has limited powers in its ability to block or amend legislation. If a government is determined to pass a piece of legislation that the Lords keeps rejecting then it can invoke the Parliament Act to force the legislation through the Lords and onto the statute books. Given the recent press stories about the apparent loans for peerages scandal that ...  Read the complete review

 
Product of the week
Top