Not such a bright choice (Maglite 3D Cell Torch)

Member Name: davomrmac

Product:	Maglite 3D Cell Torch
Date:	12/04/09 (153 review reads)
Rating:

Advantages: Well made, nice and bright

Disadvantages: Not waterproof, expensive on batteries

Maglite have been known for a long time now for their reliability and build quality. I personally think this is mainly due to good marketing. Yes, their products are good, but let me explain why there are better options.

I purchased one of these 3D cell torches. It cost me just under £20. The torch feels solid and is well made. It does what a torch is meant to do and produces a nice bright beam. The batteries last OK, but being D sized cells, they do cost a bit to replace. Rechargeables are an option, but for torch use are not that great. There are no other features on offer here. Plus, it is not particularly waterproof. Showerproof yes, but heavy rain will not do it any good.

In comparison, I purchased a Fenix torch, that runs from two AA cells. It cost me £35 and is a lot more compact. It is waterproof too. The light beam can be adjusted high to low, can be focused nicely and also it has an SOS mode, where if I did get stuck in the forest it would flash for 60 hours. The light beam it produces, with no real scientific measurement, has to be at least three times as bright. The torch also feels better made. So in comparison to the Maglite, I would choose the Fenix torch every time.

Summary: The Fenix is a much better choice