Home > Health > Health Products >

Reviews for Echinacea


Get more ooomph -  Echinacea Health Products
Echinacea 

Newest Review: ... be right, or if its too expensive - that's when we get on the front page of the news of the world. There have been quite a few stu... more

Get more ooomph (Echinacea)

MichelleScott

Member Name: MichelleScott

Product:

Echinacea

Date: 31/10/01 (669 review reads)
Rating:

Advantages: Effective, Economical

Disadvantages: Not for auto-immune sufferers

Echinacea was a word only said by earnest herbalists and new-agers until recently. Then it passed a few recognised scientific tests and became the latest thing. I think that’s a pity, as it is in danger of being as over-used as antibiotics. There are also some dangers associated with it, which I’ll explain later.

First, what is it? It is a herb which has been used for hundreds of years for stimulating the immune system. That makes it useful for times when the body’s immune system is under attack, such as during a cold or infection. The Native Americans used it (a lot – more than any other herb) and it is one of the most researched herbs in use today.

It certainly has a lot of benefits. It stimulates the activity of the body’s fighting cells, the white blood cells, which helps it throw off infections and viruses. So it doesn’t work like antibiotics, which kill bacteria, it works by helping the body to kill invaders. I read of one study that reported an increase of 50-120% in immune function when taking Echinacea.

So it does work, and it works well and quickly. It should be taken at the very first sign of a cough or cold and in a lot of cases it will stop it in its tracks (especially if accompanied by a good diet which is low in sugar – sugar kills the fighting cells).

Echinacea also has a lesser known anti-inflammatory effect as well. It is very useful for psoriasis and eczema cases and is also used by arthritis sufferers.

But here’s my problem. I have an auto-immune disease. That means that parts of my body are attacking other parts (in my case it’s thrombocytopenia, my spleen makes cells which kill the platelets in my blood). If I take Echinacea it will boost my immune system, which means I will get sicker. (Don't start wringing your hands, it's not a terribly serious auto-immune problem. It just means I'm frequently covered in bruises and look like I
've moved in with Tyson.)

So anyone with an auto-immune disorder should not take Echinacea except on specialist advice. Actually, I know my disease quite well and I do take Echinacea for one day only if I start to get a cold. If it continues though, I stop the Echinacea and just live with it. Often, though, it doesn’t continue. I can take it topically, and do so if I have an insect bite or infected cut.

If you can take it, the cheapest way is the liquid extract (it doesn't taste too bad). I buy all my herbs from Baldwins (www.baldwins.co.uk). They are experienced, efficient and economical. Echinacea is readily available in high-street chemists and health-food stores as well, in tablet and liquid form.

It is not considered wise to take Echinacea long-term as it reduces its effectiveness.

For further research, see the Herb Research Foundation (http://www.herbs.org/greenpapers/echinacea.html)

Summary:

Last members to rate this review:
(49 members total)

monty%2FDringostarr%2FevieB%2Fmumsymary%2FTigerTiger%2Fkimgraham%2F

View all 49 member ratings

Overall rating: Very useful

Nominate for a Crown:

See all newly Crowned Reviews

Last comments:
Bateleur

- 01/03/02

Interesting. I didn't know that about the sugar, nor about not taking Echinacea continuously. I've been taking it for months now, over winter (and haven't had a cold. Yipee!). I'll stop when spring comes.
mumsymary

- 24/01/02

Awhile ago Idid wonder about giving this to sleepy dormouse but decided against it as i really didnt know enough about it but maybe if she is going down with abad cold WEhave tried several other things which have not seemed to be succesfull maybe trying a couple of short courses would be a good idea
kimgraham

- 26/11/01

That was really interesting. Sorry to hear about your health problems though. That's rough. I think I might give a short course to my daughter with ME and see if it helps. She goes down with every bug going! Great op.

View all 22 comments

Top