

Newest Review: ... Under Pressure". Overall, there are 4 books in the series. Following normal teen, Ellie, girls (and boys, if you wish) can... more
Fictionalising controversial issues.
Girls Under Pressure - Jacqueline Wilson

Member Name: jennikitten
Product:
Girls Under Pressure - Jacqueline Wilson
Date: 25/05/08
Rating:
Advantages: Easy to read, range of issues covered, not condescending.
Disadvantages: Not always completely realistic, addresses sensitive issues.
The second of the 'Girls in Love' series looks at modern teen issues with eating, again from the main character Ellie's perspective. The book begins with a brief introduction to Ellie, her life and her friends and a recap of the events of the previous novel, so it's not really necessary to read the first in the series (although I recommend it!).
Eating disorders are quite taboo subjects, and to some extent it's difficult to assess what effect this writing would have on the individual reader. Even though it explores the problems and issues through a severely anorexic girl (Zoe) and Ellie's own troubles with food, it is possible that it would have an adverse effect on people with severe eating problems, triggering possible incidents or experiments. Additionally, it may prove too much for particularly sensitive readers, particularly as part of it is set in a mental hospital.
However, this is my favourite in the series; it's the most realistic, and also the most enjoyable in terms of plot development and use of interlinking story lines. It's also quite 'real' in its approach, despite the fact that the teachers seem keen to tell other students personal information about Zoe, the severe anorexic, which would never be allowed!
Similarly to the others in the series, this novel implicitly advocates a balanced, non-obsessive lifestyle and a healthy relationship with food and exercise. It is aimed at teenage (and slightly younger) girls with the aim to teach about life and its problems without getting incredibly heavy or teacher-like. Put simply, it stays grounded in the fiction genre, with the readers being left to judge and analyse characters' actions for themselves.
Overall, this is an interesting read way beyond the teenage years, but be careful about giving it as a gift to a younger/sensitive child, or one with strict parents.
Summary: One of my favourite teenage books.

