Price and Packaging: I would say the eyeliner is slightly overpriced for the quality but the packaging is fantastic - usual benefit quality! Pencil sharpens nicely without breakages and splinters, and comes with handy lid.

Application: This eyeliner goes on brilliantly if you are after the smoky look, it did not drag on my skin and the application was smooth and consistent. However, as it is a short, 'chubby' pencil, the line was thick even with a freshly sharpened pencil, so I would not recommend it for use underneath the eyes.

Wear: I applied this eyeliner before a night out and it was still there at the end of the night. It remained black (not a patchy grey) and looked perfect all night long! It did not smudge underneath my eyes like others have before and was very easy to remove with baby wipes.

Overall: I would recommend this product if you could find it for a cheaper price, it is probably not worth the price I paid for it.