Not probably, but most definitely the best mascara I have ever used! I am very fussy with my make up and often feel let down, and skint when trying to find the right product for me. I have tried so many mascaras and every time I find one I like, for some reason it ends up being discontinued, which I am beginning to think is now a curse! I had never tried a Maybeline product before as I thought the range looked cheap and tacky. This mascara came out and basically caught my eye primarily due to the fact that it was on offer as buy 2 get the third free - so obviously being a bit of a bargain hunter I thought I would invest! I went the whole hog needless to say and chanced buying 3 black mascaras, one being waterproof. I was honestly not keen on the waterproof one as I couldn't seem to get it off when I wanted to! It's perfect for holidays, beach, swimming etc but come night time, there was no budging it and seemed to smear around my face instead! The normal one is perfect. Extenuates your eyes brilliantly. My sister now uses it also and she suffers terribly with sensitive eyes, but has no problem with this mascara. Definitely the best mascara out there at the moment, and hopefully it will be out there for a while!! It is a reasonable price also.