Home > Film > Movie DVD >

Reviews for Magnolia (DVD)


Did I miss something ? -  Magnolia (DVD) Movie DVD
amazon
Magnolia (DVD) 

Newest Review: ... for Best Supporting Actor at the Academy Awards that year. It's a difficult film to summarise plot-wise, so it's easier to simply men... more

Did I miss something ? (Magnolia (DVD))

trickyd

Member Name: trickyd

Product:

Magnolia (DVD)

Date: 04/10/00 (5 review reads)
Rating:

Advantages: Passes the time

Disadvantages: Didn't add up

The film started by telling the stories of a number of 'real life' strange but true incidents, with the narrator commenting that amazing coincidences do happen. Fair enough I thought, thinking it was meant to make you believe that forthcoming implausible events and coincidences in the film could actually happen. The only problem was that what followed was perfectly plausible, so the introduction was all a bit of a waste of time. There are a number of plots running parallel in the film, each of which links by one of the characters to one or more of the others. The stories are all engaging enough, just as well as the film is about 3 hours long, but you're left wandering exactly what the point of all it was. The individual stories never really come together, which you're looking for after all the guff in the prologue about coincidence. You're left wandering if you missed the point somewhere along the line, either I did or the writer did, as you think back through the film and unsuccessfully try and put it all together. Perhaps if someone else could watch this an explain to me what it was all about ?

Summary:

Last members to rate this review:
(4 members total)

Jayne%2Fwad123%2Fcaptaincaveman%2Fcpf1993%2F

View all 4 member ratings

Overall rating: Useful

Nominate for a Crown:

See all newly Crowned Reviews

Last comments:
eyedee

- 10/01/01

the film is basically about how people are horrible to each other, tis very very boring, i feeling sleepy just thinking about it again....yawn
Jayne

- 15/10/00

I thought "Magnolia" was good in the way that it's quite original and different from other films. I guess the only real explanation as to what the point of it was that many different people can be linked to one single person/thing. If that makes any sense! I guess it's just a mysterious film.

Top