Home > Film > Movie DVD >

Reviews for The Magdalene Sisters (DVD)


A soul-shaking film. -  The Magdalene Sisters (DVD) Movie DVD
amazon
The Magdalene Sisters (DVD) 

Newest Review: ... and appreciate the freedoms they have in todays society. This is the story of four young girls who for various 'sins' find themselves ... more

A soul-shaking film. (The Magdalene Sisters (DVD))

joecooper

Member Name: joecooper

Product:

The Magdalene Sisters (DVD)

Date: 05/04/03 (197 review reads)
Rating:

Advantages: Brilliantly acted., A stunning expose.

Disadvantages: It's controversial.

Peter Mullen's controversial The Magdalene Sisters is an astonishing film that opens the mind and bleeds the heart as it exposes a true modern day horror. It reveals the shocking story of the Catholic Church's Magdalene Asylums, and the appalling crimes committed within their walls.

The Magdalene Asylums were established in Ireland during the nineteenth century, and were governed by the Catholic order of nuns known as the Sisters of Mercy. These institutions were designed to provide a source of penance for young women who were deemed to have sinned in the eyes of the church and its devout followers. With their sins suitably cleansed, the girls were to be released back into respectable society.

However, rather than being freed after a short penance, many young Catholic women were left to spend their entire lives inside the walls of the Magdalene Asylums. Until their final closure in 1996, it's estimated that some 30,000 innocent women were held against their will by the nuns, to live and die under truly appalling conditions.

Set in the 1960s, The Magdalene Sisters follows just four of the many young women thrust into the horrors of the asylums. Disowned by their families for 'moral crimes' no greater than becoming pregnant out of wedlock, Rose (Dorothy Duffy), Crispina (Emma Walsh), Bernadette (Nora-Jane Noone), and Margaret (Anne-Marie Duff) suddenly discover the system of torture and slavery that the Sisters of Mercy pass off as penance. A relentless stream of hard, unpaid labour in the nuns' sweatshop commercial laundry is only broken by harsh whippings and cruel humiliations.

The horrendous abuse is initially tolerated, as the girls believe that their release from the asylum must be imminent. Unfortunately, weeks, months, and eventually years of inhumane treatment tick by with little word from the outside world, and absolutely no indication that they'll ever be released. With despair growing in the
ir hearts, the four are forc
ed to accept the possibility of a lifetime of abuse and a lonely death within a Magdalene Asylum.

The Magdalene Sisters features a superb, if mostly unknown, cast. Newcomer Nora-Jane Noone is mesmerising and polished as the fiery Bernadette. Her performance belies the fact that before her selection in The Magdalene Sisters, Noone was living the life of an average student, working towards her science degree at the National University of Ireland. She graces the screen like a seasoned professional, when her only acting experience has been in small-scale amateur campus productions. Should she not be seduced by the temptations of a science lab, The Magdalene Sisters will herald the beginning of an illustrious acting career.

Director Mullan's stable of new talent also includes Emma Walsh. As Crispina, Walsh excels in dragging the viewer through her disturbing transformation from a bewildered and anxious young woman to a truly tormented soul. For her remarkable efforts, she collected a Best Newcomer award at the British Independent Film Awards.

The Magdalene Sisters poses some long overdue questions to the Catholic Church. As of the present, the victims of what amounts to slavery and torture have not received basic acknowledgement, let alone an apology or financial compensation. However, thanks to Peter Mullan's skill as a screenwriter and director, and the courage he's displayed in raising such a controversial topic, the matter is gaining significant momentum.

In an age where corporate glass ceilings top the feminist agenda, and human rights abuses under totalitarian regimes dominate the headlines, The Magdalene Sisters is a timely reminder that monstrous crimes against women and humanity in general can still be found very close to home.

Mullan's creation is, without a doubt, the most socially significant film of the year. Whilst not for the faint hearted, The Magdalene Sister
s carves a lasting impression and should be seen
by every adult for its revelations and for its tale of hope and endurance. It's a soul-shaking film that deserves the full five stars.


Summary:

Last members to rate this review:
(14 members total)

Densiegirl%2Fbrandygirl%2Fraehippychick%2Flitefoot%2FOphelia%2Fbinnie%2F

View all 14 member ratings

Overall rating: Very useful

Nominate for a Crown:

See all newly Crowned Reviews

Last comments:
brandygirl

- 02/05/03

I'd like to see this film sometime, but probably in the comfort of my own home. I always thought nuns were sweet ladies, having seen Julie Andrews in The Sound of Music, but this little group sound like a set of monsters. Cheers for the review.
raehippychick

- 30/04/03

doesn't sound an easy viewing, but after reading your review I know I want to see it
litefoot

- 15/04/03

Yet to see this film.I believe there was something similar on BBC1 a few months ago. Excellent review btw :)

View all 8 comments

Top