| Product: |
Supposed Former Infatuation Junkie - Alanis Morissette |
| Date: |
30/10/00 (67 review reads) |
| Rating: |
 |
Advantages: A few very good songs
Disadvantages: Too long, too wordy, too much like she's treating her listeners as her therapist
I am not a huge Alanis fan, and only bought this album because it was reduced to £3.99 or something. I think I was aware it had got some bad reviews, but quite liked the single "Thank you". My overall impressions of the album are: 1. It is too long. At over 70 minutes, it ought to be good value, but not necessarily, because? 2. there are some pretty bad songs on here. 3. her voice sounds like a mix between Sinead O'Connor, and Margaret O'Hara (mid 80's singer, with amazingly emotional delivery - whatever happened to her?). Which is OK but I'd rather listen to Sinead O'Connor or Mary Margaret O'Hara. The songs I like: "Thank you" - catchy hookline, Tori-Amos-style introduction. "Unsent" - love the tune, the words are less impressive (clumsy unsent love letters) "Your congratulations" - stark Tori-Amos style ballad with a piano / classical music accompaniment. "One" - this really could be a Mary Margaret O'Hara song. The songs I always programme out on the CD player: "Baba" - screaming / metal sound with choir-like backing vocals. That makes it sound good, but it's awful! "Heart of the house" - English folk sound with trendy syncopated drum sound, but it just sounds like her voice can't handle it (intentional or not, I find it impossible to listen to) "Would not come" - dance beat, metal guitars, awful choruses. There are many Ok songs, too, such as "Joining you" which sounds like it could have been a substandard REM tune. All in all, it seems to me that much of the album is experimental - something which I certainly would not condemn, and Morissette, perhaps more than many artists, did need to move on. But I can still understand why I was able to buy the CD for £3.99 ! Only worth getting if you see it at that kind of price.
Summary:
|
Last comment:
|
- 09/01/01 The album "jagged little pill" is much better and I dont think she will ever improve on it. |
|