| Product: |
The Bends - Radiohead |
| Date: |
31/05/01 (54 review reads) |
| Rating: |
 |
Advantages: You tell me.
Disadvantages: I can't hear what a lot of people hear in it.
I don't know if I have all the details right when I say this, but some time ago the NME conducted a survey of musicians to discover the most influential groups of all time. Number one was the Beatles. Predictable, but perfectly reasonable too. Number two was David Bowie. Not so predictable, but not so unreasonable either. Number three was... Radiohead.
My first reaction was incredulity. Radiohead? They've only been around for a decade or so, and they're the third most influential group of all time? That is some achievement, even if the survey -- and I think it must have been -- was biased in some way. Musicians who take part in surveys by the NME aren't wholly representative, after all.
But even taking that into account, it remained some achievement. So I decided to hear what the fuss was about. I felt I owed it to myself: Radiohead must be pretty darn good. Exceptionally good, in fact. So I conducted a survey of my own. On myself and my reaction to a Radiohead album. This one.
Well, I've completed the survey and can now reveal its findings. I was right to be incredulous about Radiohead coming third in that NME survey. The Beatles are special. Bowie's special too, despite everything he's done since "Let's Dance" (inclusive). Radiohead aren't. Not melodically, not lyrically, not instrumentally. Not anywhere. I liked a lot of "The Bends" in the beginning, but that wore off quickly and when I play it now it sounds, well, dreary.
And I rapidly get sick of the Weltschmerz, the narcissism, and the self-pity. Morrissey or the Manic Street Preachers do it so much better, because Morrissey does it with his tongue in his cheek (most of the time) and the Manic Street Preachers do it much more darkly and compellingly. Radiohead are lilies and languors. The Manics are roses and raptures. Black roses and black raptures. If I compare this album to "The Holy Bible", all I can say i
s that "The Bends" is the pits.
Summary:
|
Last comments:
 |
- 12/06/01 Whoops! I got jailbreakted mixed up with drown doll, sorry. |
|
|
- 12/06/01 Hmm, this is very well written, just not very well-informed. Sorry. I don't think jailbreakted was pretentious at all, merely articulate and very accurate. You don't have to do a track-by-track thing, but you should really tell us a bit about the music on the album. I didn't rate SU 'cos I disagree, but because it really was only somewhat useful. However, you can clearly write very well - if you update and include more information, I'll happily re-rate :)
- P |
 |
- 11/06/01 kfingleton --
Yes, you and hugon are probably right: this would have been a better op about the band in general.
I wasn't saying that The Bends should have been as dark as The Holy Bible (which would be difficult), but it was exploring some of the same themes without achieving anywhere as much power. To me, anyway.
Your review of THB is excellent, btw. I'd better go and mark it as such. (Dear me: how did this happen?) |
View all
12
comments
|
Deutschland 
España 
Italia 
France - 
