“ Genre: Mind, Body & Spirit / Author: Prof. Richard Wiseman / Paperback / 354 Pages / Book is published 2011-03-04 by Macmillan „
The paranormal, it seems, is a subject with seemingly limitless fascination for us, and is something which people continue to hold on to as part of their belief systems. A Gallup poll taken in 2005 indicated that 30% of people believed in ghosts and 15% claimed to have seen one. Another survey taken in 2008 had 58% of respondents stating they believed in the supernatural - more than believed in God (54%). Professor Richard Wiseman states in his latest book Paranormality that between 40% and 50% of people in the UK (and between 80% and 90% in the US) claim to have had some sort of paranormal experience. These are extraordinary figures. For all that we live in a well-educated society where science is more readily accessible than ever before, belief in the things that go bump in the night is still remarkably persistent. As an arch-sceptic and Britain's only Professor of the Public Understanding of Psychology, Wiseman has investigated the paranormal for over twenty years, and all his experience has been poured into his latest book - Paranormality: Why We See What Isn't There.
If you are expecting this to be a stern academic text with the Professor chiding us credulous members of the public for being so gullible, you would be wrong. This is a cheerful pop-science book written for those of us who find science interesting, but don't have the time, degrees or access to peer-reviewed journals that keeping up with latest developments in fields of interest would require. Here is a lot of interesting stuff compressed into 324 pages of childlike enthusiasm (plus plenty of end notes and further reading if you wish to delve further). Still don't believe me that science can be fun? Take a look at Wiseman's experiment on firewalking shown on BBC's Tomorrow's World (http://www.psy.herts.ac.uk/wiseman/research/psychics.html)
In Paranormality, Wiseman takes us on a whirlwind tour around several areas of paranormal activity - such as precognitive dreams, ghosts, fortune telling, telekinesis, mediumship and out of body experiences - pulling each apart in turn and showing us how science can provide an alternative explanation to the supernatural as to why these things happen. Be it an interesting quirk of our psychology, wishful thinking or simply a con trick, Wiseman is adamant that nothing supernatural exists. As well as cheerfully debunking all claims of such activity presented to him, he also goes one step further and argues that investigating such cases can actually reveal more about the way the human brain works. Take the case of one of the most common types of supposedly paranormal experience: the incubus (or succubus, the female form of this beastie), a monster that appears on the chest of sleepers when they awake in the night, restricting breathing and movement, and causing terrifying visions. It was once commonly believed that seeing such a vision was proof of the existence of demons, but the psychology of sleep has revealed it as a condition called sleep paralysis that happens when the brains doesn't switch correctly from sleeping to waking. Other sections on how and why our brains sometimes fail to accurately represent reality were fascinating stuff, and you can even learn how to experience lucid dreaming or an out of body experience if you so desire (I don't, so I can't tell you how successful these DIY experiences are).
While the book was well-written, full of lively examples and interesting "try it yourself" experiments, I felt it was more persuasive in some places than others. The sections relating to the psychology of sleep were especially fascinating for me as they were well backed up with convincing and quite detailed scientific explanation. However, the chapter on mediumship was nothing more than a bit of a rehash of well-worn "how to cold read" material with nothing new to offer. Anyone who has ever watched Derren Brown's TV shows or read anything on sceptical investigation will be very familiar with such material and will find nothing new here. It would serve as a decent introduction to the subject for anyone new to this sort of material, however.
I did also wonder if there was any research to be found that showed up positive evidence of any of these weird phenomenon; certainly nothing was mentioned in the book, but absence of evidence is of course not evidence of absence. It is all well and good debunking obviously silly things like the experiment to try and weigh the soul at the moment of death (21 grams, apparently), but what about looking into some good, recent scientific studies that show up evidence that these things might just exist in some way after all? You may think that in saying this I am one of those people I mentioned earlier who have had an unexplained event happen to them or who desperately want to talk to the dead - but I am not. That I am a sceptic makes me want to see these things all the more: good science tackled as well as the obviously barmy bits. If these theories are to hold up, they need to work in all circumstances, not just against the easy targets that are repeatedly presented here.
Despite my slight disappointment that this was science-lite in a few places, for the most part this is an eminently readable and enlightening tour of parapsychology that is bound to have wide appeal. Even you aren't quite convinced by one or two things, it is certainly enough to get you thinking about these effects for yourself, which has got to be a good thing. Fox Mulder once famously said that "the truth is out there", but I am more inclined to believe that the truth is in here, albeit in an introductory format.
Final rating: 3/5 - recommended to newcomers to these ideas, but less so to those who already have a familiarity with sceptical inquiry.
Paranormality: Why we see what isn't there by Professor Richard Wiseman
Published by Macmillan (2011)
324pp, Pbk, RRP £12.99
I am a bit of a skeptic when it comes to ghosts and other things that go bump in the night. I love watching the likes of Derren Brown when he sets up experiments to explain the inexplicable and am fascinated with the work of James Randi. I was really looking forward to reading 'Paranormality' by Richard Wiseman, a book which claims to explain why people see things that are not there but ended up being disappointed by it.
There are many situations when our minds, or the minds of others, are convinced that something supernatural or magic is going on. Whether that is seeing a ghost, having a dream that comes true or having a psychic predict our future many people believe there is a sixth dimension which science cannot explain. Richard Wiseman has always had an interest in parapsychology and is a professor of the public understanding of psychology so he should be the ideal person to shed some light on these subjects.
'Paranormality' takes a broad look at the subject of the paranormal and the subjects covered include spiritualism, automatic writing, phantom limbs, psychic predictions, ghosts and lucid dreaming. Each of the chapters has codes which you can use with a smart phone to connect to YouTube videos with a traditional URL for those of us who are less technically minded. There are also numerous fun experiments which you can carry out yourself at home allowing you to see a ghost, feel a phantom finger and test your memory.
The problem with 'Paranormality' is that there are far too many subjects covered so none of them are covered in any depth. The book meanders from subject to subject with no real cohesion between the different subjects being discussed in any one section. The book obviously takes the skeptics point of view but the tone towards believers in the supernatural was mocking and the alternative viewpoint is simply rubbished instead of being discussed more fully.
'Paranormality' is written in an informal manner, the fact that no scientific language is used does make it more accessible but it also makes it light and fluffy and lacking any real depth. Wiseman's numerous anecdotes and jokes ended up just irritating me, almost as if he was trying too hard to make me laugh. This banter works reasonably well in his YouTube broadcasts but in text the humour just falls flat.
This is a popular psychology book looking at various illusions rather than a serious look at the paranormal; in fact the section on cults does not seem to fit the paranormal genre at all. It is reasonably interesting and amusing in parts - I learned about Gef the talking mongoose from the Isle of Man which was fascinating- but I did not learn much from reading the book. If you have seen a lot of illusions on the internet or watched Derren Brown on TV then a lot of the material will already be familiar to you.
'Paranormality' is a pop psychology book which failed to capture my interest, if you have never read any skeptic material then it may be of interest to you but there are better sources of material out there.