Secrets of the Baby Whisperer - Tracy Hogg
Some useful ideas, but trust your judgement! - Secrets of the Baby Whisperer - Tracy Hogg Non-Fiction Book

Newest Review: ... Hogg's suggested EASY routine, and the importance of structure in a baby's life Chapter 3 ~ Explains how to respect and understand you... more

amazon

Some useful ideas, but trust your judgement!
Secrets of the Baby Whisperer - Tracy Hogg

kfir4117

Member Name: kfir4117

Product:

Secrets of the Baby Whisperer - Tracy Hogg

Date: 27/08/10

Rating:

Advantages: Great sections on interpreting babies body language and crying.

Disadvantages: This doesn't seem to apply for non textbook babies, and can offer conflicting advice to midwives

This book is nicely structured into chapters about the usual parenting bugbears (sleep, crying, breastfeeding, etc). I had hoped to pick up some tips about how to structure my daughter's day, without the rigidity of Gina Ford. However, I found this book contained hugely conflicting advice to many NHS leaflets, particularly around breastfeeding, and I actually became quite upset. There is no way I can persuade my baby to be active for 45 minutes, as per the EASY routine in this book, and my baby feeds for 5 minutes, rather than the 25-40 minutes detailed here. Rather than trusting my own instincts I allowed myself to be stressed by a routine that just isn't for me.

There is quite a cute section about identifying what sort of baby you have (Angel, Textbook, Spirited, and so on). To complete the quiz and realise you have a "grumpy" baby is a little disheartening so these labels should be taken with a pinch of salt.

There are some genuinely useful sections to read, such as how to assess what babies crying means, and ideas for sleep routines, but for a hormonal and tired mother, this book just wasn't for me.

Summary: An interesting read, but don't get bogged down in the routines.