Home > Computer > Operating System >

Reviews for Microsoft Windows XP (Whistler)


Wow, is this from Microsoft! -  Microsoft Windows XP (Whistler) Operating System
Microsoft Windows XP (Whistler) 

Newest Review: ... game and classics such as Solitaire and Reversi which can both be played online via Microsoft Gaming Zone. Many have said that this o... more

Wow, is this from Microsoft! (Microsoft Windows XP (Whistler))

mykp

Member Name: mykp

Product:

Microsoft Windows XP (Whistler)

Date: 10/01/02 (396 review reads)
Rating:

Advantages: Doesnt Crash, Looks Superb, Handles like a dream

Disadvantages: have to activate it, its not cheap, There will be a new version in the near future

Windows XP

Many years ago, when PC operating systems where still in their text only domain, there came along an operating system which made us all sit up, take notice and say WOW!.

That Operating system was Windows 95.

Now since Windows 95 came along there have been lots of newer versions of Windows 95 but they have never been radically different in look, feel or buggy-ness.

That is until Microsoft's latest incarnation of Windows fell on to the market.

So, called Windows XP (XP box is raised to the heavens and angels cry Windows XP)

Alright so, what is this XP, what does it do? where does it do it and most importantly does it work.

After playing with XP now for a suitable period of time and having messed with all the new toys that come with it and tried to break them, I have to say that Microsoft have produced a Peach this time, and not the usual moldy, smelly, lemon.

Why do I say this? Well my previous complaint about earlier versions of Windows was that you had to install them to see if they would work. With XP, it actually performs a compatibility check of your system before you install it. Reporting any devices or programs (if you're upgrading a previous version) which might not work, might require new drivers or might have a problem with.

For me this reported 2 devices which wouldn't work and 5 programs which would not work (I upgraded from Win 2000 Pro). The devices which wouldn't work, where my Kodak DC210 and my Astra Umax Scanner. These where very device driver problems and just required a simple uninstall and then reinstalling. The software problems where again very minor, and only required uninstalling and reinstalling. However as I have PC Anywhere 9 installed I don't get the fancy login screen anymore. :(

So after you?ve installed it what's it like?

Well, the interface is much the same as previous versions of Windows only the desig
n has changed, for the better in my opinion, now everything is bright and blue with nice round edges and shaded boxes.

You can however return the look back to the same as previous versions of Windows, but everybody I know has kept the new interface as it's much more pleasing to the eye.

It will take you time to get used to where certain icons are, as they have been moved around, but after a while it does make the use of the machine easier than before. However if you upgrade from a previous version of Windows it will keep your start menu and desktop settings. (Very useful indeed).

If you're going to do a vanilla install then I might suggest that you spend a little extra money or time on a good book or on viewing the tutorials that come with XP.

I am not going to go into specifics about what's been put where and how to do this and that, (although I'm sure somebody will whinge about not doing!), But I will say that I have never been so excited (I know it's sad!) about an operating system than I am about XP.

Installing is a doddle, although on slower machines it does take time. From a usability point it takes some time to get used to (took me about 4 days, so Mr Average about a week to 10 days), your programs will behave better and if XP does crash it won't require a full reboot.

I have had my work machine switched on and running XP for over 3 months and the number of reboots must be under 10. If something does crash then the application will usually terminate itself or pressing Control, Alt and Delete together will bring up the Task Manager so you can kill the application.

I know you?re all asking "What's the benefit for me?" Well, I can only see a few advantages for the home user as this is the Professional version, but it is however very similar to the home version. (I bought the Professional version over the home version as in my experience Pro software is usually mo
re polished and bug free than home versions, albeit more expensive). The security is much better on then on Win 95 or 98, there is support for multi users logins, Plug and Play support is much better.

For the professional the network support is brilliant and to set an XP machine up on a network takes seconds and doesn't require a reboot.

The advantages for the home user are mainly cosmetic. Its easier to learn as everything is big and bold, it has vastly greater security than previous versions of Windows, plus it has multiple user functionality (ideal if you have kids and want to keep your data and there data separate). It also looks and works miles better than Win 95/98.

There have been a number of security problems already relating to XP but these have been fixed very fast by Microsoft and as with previous versions you can go to Windows update to get the latest fixes and patches for nothing.

So for me XP gets the big thumbs up, its nice to look at, doesn't crash as much as previous versions of windows, is easier to use and I love it. :)

If you want to get a copy it requires a 300 MHz + processor, 128Mbytes Ram, 1.5 Gig Hard drive space, SVGA 800 x 600 or higher Video Card and everything else is additional.

Cost is £240 give or take a few pence and the home version is price at £160, near as damn it. The upgrades are £160 for the Pro and £80 for the Home.

I do have two major gripes about XP however and thats if one fo your programs does crash it always, always asks if you wish to report this fault to Microsoft. I wish there was a way to switch it off. The other gripe is you have to activate it. I can understand the reason Microsoft have done it but it makes you wonder what information is being sent to Microsoft.

If you're fed up of having those blue screens on Windows 95/98/ME then have a look at XP. In my humble opinion it makes the older versions of Windows look and feel old and
tired and completely out of date.

If you're buying a new machine make sure it has XP on it as you won't regret it. If you're thinking of upgrading then look no further than XP, it will give your PC that new lease of life it's been begging.

Summary:

Last members to rate this review:
(15 members total)

rob_writer%2Fskir67%2Fdaseaford%2Fmissbrowneyedgirl%2FNikkiH%2Fmodernity%2F

View all 15 member ratings

Overall rating: Very useful

Nominate for a Crown:

See all newly Crowned Reviews

Last comments:
mykp

- 11/01/02

nice one del, will try that.
Del_Boy

- 11/01/02

mykp, you can change the auto reporting function, do this:

Windows Key + Pause/Break
Advanced Tab
Error Reporting Tab at the bottom
and change the error reporting settings from there.

Kev
mykp

- 10/01/02

done the ????'s my machine has Japanese language support and it dont like copy and paste from word!

View all 5 comments

Product of the week
Top