Home > Books & Magazines > Printed Book >

Reviews for The Catcher in the Rye - J. D. Salinger


DooYoo understand? -  The Catcher in the Rye - J. D.  Salinger Printed Book
amazon
The Catcher in the Rye - J. D. Salinger 

Newest Review: ... other word seemed to be either 'depressed' or 'phony' - they turned up pretty much every page! This sort of sums up what the book was about... more

DooYoo understand? (The Catcher in the Rye - J. D. Salinger)

yorkrap007

Member Name: yorkrap007

Product:

The Catcher in the Rye - J. D. Salinger

Date: 15/06/01 (42 review reads)
Rating:

Advantages: No one understands the book, protrays the imaturity of teens, ironic (who's the true catcher)

Disadvantages: everyone thinks they understand holden, everyone thinks they are holden

Everyone views holden as the depressed teenager that gets a bad deal in life. This is absolute bullshit. Hold Caufield is such a great character because he places himself in situations where trouble will find him. He purposely lives his life to appear sad and depressed, he tries to be the unknown hero that gets noticed and eventually praised. Thiank about it... yes Holden is upset that Allie died, but the reason he is depressed, and not merely sad is because he thinks that he should be. If he were really depressed, why not kill himself and get it over with, instead of finding stupid reasons not to do so. If hold would have committed suicide, then he truely would have been a depressed individual, but because he didn't shows his fradulent feelings and emotions. Those emotions only exist because Holden want them to exist. True depression is not wanting saddness, but longing for contentment. I'm done... and I know many will see my view as wrong, but who cares... it's my opinion.

Summary:

Last members to rate this review:
(13 members total)

janharper%2Fjillmurphy%2Ffrannyfortune%2FDuncan1%2Fgollygumdrops%2Ftinkerflip%2F

View all 13 member ratings

Overall rating: Useful

Nominate for a Crown:

See all newly Crowned Reviews

Last comments:
jillmurphy

- 16/06/01

What alkaliguru said (how dare he get here first!), with the addition of welcome to dooyoo!
frannyfortune

- 16/06/01

Ermm..."different&qu ot; sort of name, btw. Are we all crap? Or just some of us?
frannyfortune

- 16/06/01

Welcome to dooyoo - King H is right really, there is nothing here for someone who hasn't read the book. Other than that, it was interesting. Hope you keep writing :-)

View all 5 comments

Top