| Product: |
Children and Television - Barrie Gunter, Jill McAleer |
| Date: |
16/08/00 (135 review reads) |
| Rating: |
 |
Advantages: Well written, solid scientific research
Disadvantages: None
Does TV make children violent, or antisocial? Very often people - in particular parents - discuss these questions in emotional and heated debates, unaware of the psychological research in this area. However, often opinions based purely on strong emotions may lead astray, and if you really want to know which aspects of TV are harmful or beneficial, then a knowledge of the scientific research is essential. The book "Children and TV" by Barrie Gunter and Jill McAleer provides exactly this, and it does so in a very readable and easily understandable style, without oversimplifying the facts. It is well organised in chapters that discuss one particular question like "Does TV influence aggressive behaviour?", so you don't have to read it from beginning to end, but rather pick the questions that you are most interested in. Mind you, not for every question raised there is a clear and straightforward answer, sometimes the answer will be different from what one naively expects, and sometimes the research has not given any answer at all. In general, even small children are not passive recipients of whatever is being presented on TV, but viewing is an active process where one's previous knowledge, attitudes and cognitive abilities shape to a certain degree actively what you understand - unfortunately this review is too short to give more details (read the book!). Although the book is written in a clear and concise manner, don't expect always easy reading. The subject is complex, with sometimes conflicting evidence, so it requires some active effort: I found myself reading a few pages, thinking about them, going back to previous parts, comparing different chapters - in short, a very stimulating experience. I feel that the authors have succeeded in making a complex matter accessible to a wide audience of non-specialists. The book will give you a clearer understanding of the effect of TV on children, based on sound scientific research, a
nd it will give you an indication what to look out for if you are worried about the influence of TV. Even for people without children it is highly interesting reading: Haven't we all been children, and isn't TV still an important part of our everyday life? Children and Television Barrie Gunter, Jill McAleer Paperback - 280 pages (January 1997) Routledge, an imprint of Taylor & Francis Books Ltd; ISBN: 0415144523 £13.99
Summary:
|
Last comments:
|
- 27/08/00 As a parent I am often presented with viewing choices for my children. I am not inclined to censor them as I have always felt that a stable and happy home life with sensible role models will inform their behaviour and outlook to a far larger degree. They already have a view of war which, in my peacenik opinion, is mature beyond their years. However, I regret to say that watching Power Rangers (the woes of playground peer pressure) has altered their behaviour for the worse. I shall certainly buy this book - it may well influence future strategies! |
|
- 24/08/00 How I came to reading the book?
Well, I don't really know.
Probably because again and again I got dragged into heated debates about violence and TV, or whether the X-Files makes people more gullible, or similar things.
I felt that the discussions didn't get anywhere, because everybody's arguments - including my own - were mostly guesswork and prejudices, but little solid evidence for one opinion or the other.
So I wanted to know what psychological research has to say about the media effects. A while later I found this book by chance.
|
|
- 16/08/00 This sounds a good book- similar to the stuff i studied at university only more useful! If I get time I might try to find it. Your review doesn't mention how you came to be reading such a book though- not the usual summer holiday reading! |
View all
4
comments
|