Home > Books & Magazines > Printed Book >

Reviews for Computing for Dummies


Only a Dummy would buy this! -  Computing for Dummies Printed Book
amazon
Computing for Dummies 

Newest Review: ... can change around programs (but you need to be a little bit of a hacker as well) C++ also gives you the power to write games and softwar... more

Only a Dummy would buy this! (Computing for Dummies)

Welshlad

Member Name: Welshlad

Product:

Computing for Dummies

Date: 24/01/01 (24 review reads)
Rating:

Advantages: Decent Networking stuff

Disadvantages: Half useless!

Networking for Dummies
----------------------

I bought his book expecting something of a beginners guide to home networking, and was sadly disappointed. While the book does give an introduction to home networking (and a good enough one at that), it tried hard to be more than it is, and fails miserably. By this, I mean the sections where it tries (and fails badly) to give a guide to installing Linux and other completely unrelated and needless inclusions that spoil what is a potentially very useful book.
If you buy this book expecting to use it as your starters bible for home networking, you will be disappointed by the fact that 30% is useless information that does not belong in this book.

The accompanying fact sheets inside the covers that appear in all of the dummies books I have seen are present again, and these to are very useful for a quick reference, with handy info available at a glance (e.g. valid range of private IP address values etc) but this isn’t enough in all honesty.

That said there are every useful sections of planning and installing your networking, as well as recent inclusions such as ICS, BackOffice and various other section that are well worth learning. If only this book had stuck to its task, it would have been a real top seller!

There are far better books out there on networking that stick to the task and do an altogether better job. Unfortunately, this one does NOT doe exactly what it says in the tin!
Definitely a missed opportunity!

Summary:

Last members to rate this review:
(18 members total)

SciSoft%2Fonionbag%2FAnyoldone%2FCold-Fusion%2FNikkimogg%2FBish%2F

View all 18 member ratings

Overall rating: Useful

Nominate for a Crown:

See all newly Crowned Reviews

Last comments:
Welshlad

- 27/01/01

GroundZero: Thanks for pointing that one out - I knew I missed something ;)
Changes dully made...
GroundZero

- 25/01/01

Just a guess, but is this book Networking For Dummies? Call me a dummy if you like ;-) but I don't see the title mentioned in the review. Used this book last year at uni and it seems OK in patches. The Perl Dummies book is actually quite good - see my review elsewhere.
Welshy

- 24/01/01

While your review is very accurate, I guess we were just looking for different things from this book...See my review to see my thoughts...

Top