Welcome! Log in or Register

Echoes From The Dead - Johan Theorin

  • image
£2.00 Best Offer by: amazon.co.uk marketplace See more offers
2 Reviews

Genre: Crime / Thriller / Author: Johan Theorin / 480 pages / Book published 2009-07-03 by Black Swan

  • Sort by:

    * Prices may differ from that shown

  • Write a review >
    How do you rate the product overall? Rate it out of five by clicking on one of the hearts.
    What are the advantages and disadvantages? Use up to 10 bullet points.
    Write your reviews in your own words. 250 to 500 words
    Number of words:
    Write a concise and readable conclusion. The conclusion is also the title of the review.
    Number of words:
    Write your email adress here Write your email adress

    Your dooyooMiles Miles

    2 Reviews
    Sort by:
    • More +
      31.12.2011 01:59
      Very helpful
      1 Comment



      A thoughtful mystery story that focuses on relationships and a killer's history.

      This book was recommended to me by a member of my book group. It is a Nordic crime thriller, the author's first book, and was voted Best First Mystery Novel by the Swedish Academy of Crime.

      -- A lost child. A buried secret. A truth worth killing for. --

      It's all there in the strapline. In 1972 on Oland a young boy clambers over his grandparents' wall to go exploring. A thick fog rolls in and he is soon lost. A strange man materialises out of the fog, introduces himself as Nils, Nils Kant, and holds out a hand to the boy. The child, Jens, is never seen again. His mother, Julia, cannot accept he is dead.

      Twenty years later, one of the boy's shoes arrives in his grandfather Gerlof's post-box. Summoning his daughter, Jens' mother, they begin to investigate the past. Someone knows something, but what? And who? What really happened out there in the fog? Someone knows, and they're closer than Julia thinks...

      -- Twenty years ago... --

      The prologue tells the story of Jens' disappearance in a simple but chilling way. I felt that it was a gripping introduction to the storyline and I found myself returning to it at several points as the story developed. Two distinct mysteries develop: what happened to the boy and who was the man he met in the fog? I felt that this was a very effective start to the plot.

      The story follows two paths as it progresses, alternating between Gerlof and Julia's investigation and the life of famed Oland villain Nils Kant. Following Nils from his childhood, it becomes clear that he is an egoistic, unpleasant child with a propensity for violence. Some Olanders believe that he could have killed Jens, but there is a flaw in their theory: Nils Kant died in 1962...or did he? If he didn't, whose body is buried in his grave? The two stories dovetail neatly together, sometimes repeating or reinforcing ideas but always developing in a logical way. I felt that the way the stories developed slowly heightened the focus on the storytelling.

      As for Julia, her investigation is more than a laying to rest of ghosts. It brings her back to life, helps to heal a fractured relationship with her father and even brings the hint of a new romance. This does mean that the pace of the story is very slow. Things happen; they are reflected upon, discussed, assimilated. There are some deaths and sudden events but much of the story is taken up with discussion and thought. This meant that although I found the story interesting, I did not find it gripping. There did not seem to be any great urgency to the story, perhaps because the key events had all taken place in the past. This is not a criticism and is largely due to the nature of the principal characters: retired men and a grieving mother.

      Towards the end of the story there is a greater sense of urgency but the tone remains largely calm and detached. I was able to anticipate the main elements of the ending in advance which also helped to create quite a gentle sense of closure, even when the events were actually quite violent. I felt the ending was satisfying as it was plausible and tied up all the loose ends. I also liked that the ending felt realistic - the discoveries made do not result in a magical, beautiful fixing of all faults; the ending is more nuanced than that, and is all the better for it. There is an epilogue related in a way that is distanced from the main characters and I felt that this worked well to create a sense of closure.

      From the opening pages Theorin evokes a great sense of place and this is sustained throughout the story, which is deeply atmospheric. Theorin's familiarity with the island - his mother's family lived on it for centuries and he is a frequent visitor - is evident and helps to create a convincing setting. There is a helpful map next to the prologue but I found that the story could be enjoyed without repeated reference to it. The harshness of the Alvar, a sort of wild meadow, is sharply evoked early on and so its threat is well established before it becomes a principal scene in the more dramatic part of the novel. I felt that the story was well structured as it became darker as it continued.

      I found Gerlof to be a slightly irritating character as he does seem to try to heighten his own importance by withholding information from his anxious daughter. Theorin dwells almost lovingly on the indignities or Gerlof's old age and accompanying illnesses, which is not something I found particularly interesting. I found Julia's situation more sympathetic although I imagine some readers may be frustrated by her extended refusal to face reality prior to the story beginning. I found the relationship between these characters formed the heart of the book which made it different to other crime stories I have read. Of course, readers who are more interested in the crime may find this exasperating.

      -- Conclusions --

      This is a slow burning story which will suit a reader with patience and an interest in story and character relationships as well as plot. Due to the age and nature of the main characters it has a calm feel despite some dramatic events. The story develops in a way which is gently predictable but this is not a criticism - the events are predictable because of the careful way Theorin unfolds the story, not because they are thoughtlessly slotted together. I did not find that being able to anticipate later events dimmed my interest at all. If anything, the desire to have my theories confirmed heightened my interest in the story. I would recommend this story to fans of atmospheric, slow paced mysteries.

      This edition seems to be well-translated; the dialogue and description throughout felt natural and flowed well. The font is clear and easy to read. Sections within chapters are clearly separated and signposted, especially when the narrative switches from Julia to Nils. There are some pictures from Oland and of Theorin's family at the end of the book which I felt was rather self-indulgent but some readers might appreciate the opportunity to gain more of a 'feeling' for what Oland is like. The RRP is £7.99, so fairly typical, and not bad for 468 pages of story. It can be found for less online.


      Login or register to add comments
      • More +
        01.04.2011 03:18
        Very helpful



        On a holiday island, a darker past is revealed

        More than twenty years ago, Julia's 5 year old son Jens went missing and was never found. They were on holiday visiting her parents. She doesn't know what happened to him, and is now depressed, living on sickness benefits and drinking too much wine. Then her father, Gerlof, rings for the first time in nearly a year, to tell her someone has sent him Jens' sandal. This prompts Julia and Gerlof to start trying to find out what really happened all those years ago, in the hope that, if nothing else, they can move on.

        A lot of evidence points to Nils Kant, who was known to be an unpleasant, sadistic man, and the story of the present day investigation is interspersed with flashbacks to his life from childhood. I'm not sure about some of the flashbacks, as we don't learn so much about what makes him bad, we just get lots of examples of it. There is also contradictory evidence though, which casts some doubt that Nils Kant killed Jens.

        I am a bit wary of missing children stories, but I was curious about a new to me Swedish writer and this sounded interesting enough to overcome my prejudice. The novel is quite long at 480 pages and seemed quite slow paced at first, but gradually I was drawn into the story. Both Julia and her dad were quite remote characters and felt difficult to get to know, but gradually they began to seem more real and engaged my sympathy. Julia also gets help and support from a local policeman and she and Lennart become increasingly attracted to each other.

        The problem of being unable to come to terms with what has happened because of not knowing was something I could identify with, and it also explained the remoteness of the characters for me - Julia especially has withdrawn into herself.

        The setting of Echoes from the Dead is interesting - Oland is a real island, popular with Swedes as a holiday place, but very harsh and cold in the winter, and this inhospitable weather becomes part of the plot. Theorin himself spent summers there from childhood, and has now set 4 novels there.

        Echoes of the Dead has been referred to as the first book in a series, but it reads more like a standalone. I wonder if they're linked by their common setting on Oland rather than recurring characters?

        Finally, once I got into the book, the many twists and turns of the plot kept me turning the pages.

        Echoes from the Dead is an atmospheric debut and I will certainly be looking for Johan Theorin's other novels.

        I was sent a copy of this book by the publisher, Transworld, to review as part of their Great Crime Caper challenge.


        Login or register to add comments

      Products you might be interested in