Home > Books & Magazines > Printed Book >

Reviews for Hannibal - Thomas Harris


Good start and middle.... -  Hannibal - Thomas Harris Printed Book
amazon
Hannibal - Thomas Harris 

Newest Review: ... knows his audience are smart people. The plot involves numerous crazy moments, but revolves around a former acquaintance of Lecter's name... more

Good start and middle.... (Hannibal - Thomas Harris)

josollsam

Member Name: josollsam

Product:

Hannibal - Thomas Harris

Date: 19/05/01 (32 review reads)
Rating:

Advantages: Beautifully written

Disadvantages: Terrible ending

Having read 'silence of the lambs' I was very much looking forward to reading 'Hannibal'. I wanted to know more about him as a free man.

I find Hannibal, although a murderer and a cannibal, someone who was charming, likeable, and fascinating. Which is a srange way to feel about someone so 'evil'.

Clarise Starling, heroine of 'silence of the lambs' is also a character who I would like to remain 'friends' with, she is also fascinating, but for different reasons. She is honest, determined, stubborn and a bit vulnerable.

We also have Mason and his sister Margot, Mason being the real evil one here and we can't feel sympathy towards him at all, even though he is suffering. I am glad he is suffering. Margot, well, she is a bit of a non-entity but she's alright!

There are a few more characters who we either like or don't and on the whole I am satisfied with how they all either move on or get caught out.

Except for Hannibal and Clarise. The book ending is so far-fetched, so surreal and so fairy tale-like that it is incredibly disappointing.

Thomas Harris has a great way of putting words together in sentences that are like eating some of the (food) delicacies hannibal enjoys. Harris makes you savour each phrase, sometimes it is necessary to reread a paragraph just because it is pleasurable to do so. You are pulled along, aching to find out what happens to each person and then........well, nothing.

Worth a read though, just for the poetic way Harris writes, but be prepared to wonder what happened to make Harris appear to suddenly either not be able to find a proper ending, or whether he just went on a flight of fancy, forgetting what he had written beforehand.

Summary:

Last members to rate this review:
(17 members total)

Going+To+California%2FMrPopeye%2Fcbpotts%2Fgeorge_lazenby%2FMR.COATES%2Fidodoyou%2F

View all 17 member ratings

Overall rating: Very useful

Nominate for a Crown:

See all newly Crowned Reviews

Last comments:
cbpotts

- 12/11/01

Great job. I like a book review that doesn't just rewrite the book for us. Like you I thought the ending was so far out of character and farfetched it didn't make sense. - Christiane
MrPopeye

- 29/08/01

Did the story in any way relate to the original "manhunter" book? Or has the author, like Hollywood conveniently forgotten their past errors now that the money train came in?
cbpotts

- 18/07/01

I agree with your op. Thought it was far fetched and hated the ending. Totally took Clarice out of character to end it that way, don't you think?

View all 8 comments

Top