Home > Books & Magazines > Printed Book >

Reviews for Harry Potter Series - J. K. Rowling in general


Harry Potter books or Worst Witch Copy? -  Harry Potter Series - J. K. Rowling in general Printed Book
amazon
Harry Potter Series - J. K. Rowling in general 

Newest Review: ... books (at the time only nubers one to 4 were out) were being hyped up too much. However i was forced to read The philosophers stone at a... more

Harry Potter books or Worst Witch Copy? (Harry Potter Series - J. K. Rowling in general)

marija

Member Name: marija

Product:

Harry Potter Series - J. K. Rowling in general

Date: 31/07/01 (98 review reads)
Rating:

Advantages: good easy read, imaginative, good vs. evil

Disadvantages: hard for younger children, no paperback

I was very happy to finally get a hold of all the Harry Potter series and I have now read them twice! As a 41-year-old woman I found them quite good and very enjoyable easy reading!
However I was sort of distressed when I began to watch a series from the UK called Worst Witch! I wondered just how much Ms. J.K. Rowling has taken from this show? Now I'm wondering if the writer's of worst witch have been also seeing the closeness of theme, style and subject matter?
Is the Harry Potter series a rip-off of earlier writers efforts? Hey it's pretty easy to change a few things and have the stories nearly the same but still different! It just seems odd that I haven’t heard anyone say anything about this!
I hope that Fans of Worst Witch and Harry Potter can see that there are several strong similarities between the two I guess you can enjoy both of them as I do, then try to decide which came first! And which is better?

Summary:

Last members to rate this review:
(17 members total)

bebionc%2Fukthing%2Fdrdel%2Fdefiler%2Fdaiquiri%2Fcsaldanha%2F

View all 17 member ratings

Overall rating: Somewhat useful

Nominate for a Crown:

See all newly Crowned Reviews

Last comments:
ukthing

- 28/08/01

I see what you mean about the similarities, but i still really like harry potter boioks, and i think they are better than the worst witch series, but thats just my opinion!
drdel

- 01/08/01

Haven't even heard of Worst Witch but I have read Harry Potter and it is harmless fun as far as i am concerned and it seems to make a lot of kids very happy. By the way I was recommended The Earthsea Quartet by Ursula LeGun. Have you read this?
defiler

- 01/08/01

Welcome to dooyoo, as other people have said you make a good point but don't really go into enough details on the books.

View all 9 comments


Top