Home > Books & Magazines > Printed Book >

Reviews for How to be good - Nick Hornby


Is this love?! -  How to be good - Nick Hornby Printed Book
amazon
How to be good - Nick Hornby 

Newest Review: ... on their marriage. Close to divorce, David suddenly undergoes a transformation - he himself now wants to do 'good' in the world, but h... more

Is this love?! (How to be good - Nick Hornby)

eddiegreen

Member Name: eddiegreen

Product:

How to be good - Nick Hornby

Date: 05/07/01 (49 review reads)
Rating:

Advantages: Big Print

Disadvantages: Long-Winded, Too Descriptive, Boring

How To Be Good is not about how to be good!

Confused?

Nick Hornby has written this novel from the viewpoint of a woman GP who has just had an affair, her husband is going nuts and she's basically bored.

The book itself is too long-winded, he has subjected us to several chapters of descriptions rather than just story telling.

The book itself teaches a very good lesson to young lovers though, that Love is not just being able to hold hands in the park, or wanting to rip each others clothes off, it's about sticking by even though neither of you are happy, because it's a partnership.

Although I am a great fan of Hornbys previous work, I have to admit that this book fell well short of his usual 5 star rating. He must be struggling to find new ways of writing to produce a book that cannot grab your attention.

The only reason I wanted to finish it was to see what happened to a young Faith-Healer called GoodNews.

Don't buy this book, get it from the library if you have too.


Summary:

Last members to rate this review:
(11 members total)

triplecthegame%2Ffizzle%2Fq7179%2Frobqueen%2Fhugon%2Fdreamerz%2F

View all 11 member ratings

Overall rating: Useful

Nominate for a Crown:

See all newly Crowned Reviews

Last comments:
shanecahill

- 06/07/01

I agree with spacelamb, maybe it's that he is not as good at writing as a woman?
Shane
spacelamb

- 05/07/01

What a disappointment - I loved High Fidelity and About A Boy.
pollee

- 05/07/01

One question - how have you had the opportunity to read it if it's not published yet? Tell me your secret and I'll use it next time a Harry Potter book comes out!

Top