Home > Books & Magazines > Printed Book >

Reviews for A Landing on the Sun - Michael Frayn


30-ish male (little or no SOH) seeks company for clandestine excursions into emotional perspective  -  A Landing on the Sun - Michael Frayn Printed Book
amazon
A Landing on the Sun - Michael Frayn 

Newest Review: ... to this book than meets the eye. It has real human emotions such as humour and tragedy. The humour comes from Serrafin and Summerchild’s w... more

30-ish male (little or no SOH) seeks company for clandestine excursions into emotional perspective (A Landing on the Sun - Michael Frayn)

jodhen

Member Name: jodhen

Product:

A Landing on the Sun - Michael Frayn

Date: 13/02/01 (46 review reads)
Rating:

Advantages: Best line: "He feels. That is his great mistake." Best scene - see below.

Disadvantages: Mockery of civil servants - not neccesarily big, but definitely clever

Have you ever read a book you love but been clueless about the origins of its title? “A Landing on the Sun” is one of those books for me. (The title has probably got some allegorical significance that I’m completely ignorant about. If you know, please let me in on it. The only explanation I can find for the title of this novel is its interest in the shiny roofs of government buildings where the tiles aren’t the only things to get hot.)

“A Landing on the Sun” is the story of Jessel, a civil servant who seems quite satisfied with his job, which as the novel begins, is to report on the Annual Assessment of Departmental Efficiency. The orderly world of his work, with its neat files and sensible, accurate minutes is certainly a comfort to him, contrasting as it does with the chaos of his household; an institutionalised wife, an emotionally unstable son, an over-apologetic mother-in-law.

If all this sounds tedious, depressing and exactly the opposite of what you consider to be a good read, please don’t stop reading this opinion yet! Jessel’s tidy work environment is topsy-turvied when he is asked to investigate the possibly mysterious circumstances of the death of Stephen Summerchild, a fellow civil servant who is apparently even more civil and servile than Jessel, in the mid-seventies. This brings work and home into uncomfortably close quarters, reminding him of a childish pursuit of Summerchild’s daughter, and he gradually realises that there are more things in heaven and earth than dreamt of…, well if not in his philosophy, at least in the dusty turrets of Westminster.

The so-called mystery surrounding Summerchild’s death becomes fairly quickly apparent to the reader, and it is Jessel’s alternately naïve and wilful misreading of events which provides us with our entertainment. Gradually – and clumsily, reluctantly, pompously, irritatingly and very funnily ̵
1; Jessel comes to terms with what he discovers in a series of transcripts of taped conversations between Summerchild and his director in the "Strategy Unit", Dr Serafin. Sometimes the boundaries blur - disconcerting for us, but surely one civil servant’s life is much the same as another’s? – so that Jessel cannot distinguish between himself and the subject of his inquiry. Sometimes he seems to be on the brink of overcoming his emotional impotence – disconcerting for him, longed for by us. Just when I’m beginning to sympathise with the man, I find myself laughing at his ill-conceived, sanctimonious judgements. Just as the laughter fades into pity, Frayn takes off into absurdity again.

Michael Frayn’s achievement in this novel lies in the subtle and economic way he manoeuvres the reader (using the device of the unreliable narrator to great effect, like Ishiguro’s butler Stevens in “The Remains of the Day”). He leads us gently between the ridiculous and the sublime, from sympathy to amusement, through a philosophical discourse on the notion of happiness, along the edge of a detective novel, by way of a spoof of civil servant life, towards a small human drama. And the honey and celery scene alone makes it worth reading.



Summary:

Last members to rate this review:
(5 members total)

pje%2Fdebod%2FTrevor15%2FMatt+B%2Fjillmurphy%2F

View all 5 member ratings

Overall rating: Very useful

Nominate for a Crown:

See all newly Crowned Reviews

Last comments:
Chris_Co

- 15/02/03

Several allusions in the novel explain the title, jodhen. The Oxford academic who turns the investigation of the 'quality of life' into an investigation of the idea of happiness, and then into a search for happiness, refers to happiness at one point as something like 'the sun of our conceptual system'. The narrator (who seems to me to have a pretty well developed, but melancholy, sense of humour - Frayn's sense of humour, in fact), then compares the work that she and her civil-servant lover are engaged in to a government-sponsored mission to the sun.

Frayn could have called the book 'A Mission to the Sun', but the choice of the word 'Landing' reflects the fact that the academic and the civil servant achieve happiness, briefly, at the end.

i finished the book minutes ago. It was certainly my cup of civil-service tea - like everything by Frayn.
debod

- 04/03/01

Sounds good. Landing on the Sun... hmm... something to do with Icarus? Or just an extremely perilous endeavour that would require immense NASAesque organization, and would lead to hot air?
Matt+B

- 14/02/01

Your opinion was excellent, Jodhen. In particular I liked the way you formed your 'advantages' section. The book, however, does not sound like my cup of tea. That said, once I've finished my big book backlog that I have to go through, I may well seek this out at my local library...

Top