Home > Books & Magazines > Printed Book >

Reviews for A Monk Swimming - Malachy McCourt


Swim Malachy Swim! -  A Monk Swimming - Malachy McCourt Printed Book
amazon
A Monk Swimming - Malachy McCourt 

Newest Review: ... search for fame, fortune, fun and freedom in America, beginning at the age of twenty, having only recently arrived and found casual e... more

Swim Malachy Swim! (A Monk Swimming - Malachy McCourt)

matthewnice

Member Name: matthewnice

Product:

A Monk Swimming - Malachy McCourt

Date: 14/05/01 (86 review reads)
Rating:

Advantages: Well written, look for the holywood stars

Disadvantages: a tale not finished

Having just put the book down after a frantic two days trying to find time to read, I felt I had to rush to the aid of Malachy and defend an excellently written book.

Malachy by his own admission is a bit of a charmer, a bit of a ladies man and more than partial to the odd drink – Hence the title. Malachy’s story begins as with his brother’s sequel to Angela’s Ashes with Malachy’s arrival in New York. This however is where the similarities with his brother Frank end. Malachy is his own man and struggling to find his way in the world. Armed only with a sharp wit and the Irish charm Malachy manages to charm his way in to jobs, and then drink his way back on to the dole.

Fans of brother Franks books will recall some of the events told in this book, yet Malachy has a way of telling them so that you always end up seeing things from his point of view. As he finds his way in America Malachy has more ups and downs than Reginald Perrin but always seems to come up smelling of roses.

In my opinion, the book is excellently and honestly written, it is not bogged down with every detail of life as Franks Tis had a tendency to do. If I have to have a gripe its that you don’t feel that all of Malachy’s tale is told at the end. This is probably deliberate as he has a sequel in mind. If he does, I for one will be all too happy to part with some more cash and support Malachys alcohol fund.

Summary:

Last members to rate this review:
(11 members total)

jillmurphy%2FTrevor15%2Fgollygumdrops%2Ftinkerflip%2FSquiggles%2Fbrianlfc%2F

View all 11 member ratings

Overall rating: Useful

Nominate for a Crown:

See all newly Crowned Reviews

Last comments:
gollygumdrops

- 15/05/01

Not knowledgeable Jill, just Catholic ;)
jillmurphy

- 14/05/01

Gosh, that Golly is soooo knowledgable isn't she! And here's me soooo ignorant - I didn't even know Frank's brother wrote too. I may even read!
Trevor15

- 14/05/01

I wasn't going to bother with this, believing that it was creaming a profit from 'Tis. Perhaps that was unfair of me. Shall now order it from Amazon ;-) Thanks.

View all 4 comments

Top