Home > Books & Magazines > Printed Book >

Reviews for The New York Trilogy - Paul Auster


Identity -  The New York Trilogy - Paul Auster Printed Book
amazon
The New York Trilogy - Paul Auster 

Newest Review: ... City of Glass, involves a writer, Daniel Quinn, whose wife and child are dead. He receives a series of phone calls from a man asking f... more

Identity (The New York Trilogy - Paul Auster)

annalindsay

Member Name: annalindsay

Product:

The New York Trilogy - Paul Auster

Date: 24/07/03 (162 review reads)
Rating:

Advantages: absorbing

Disadvantages: don't expect a conventional detective story!

It was one of those books you pick almost at random: recommended by Waterstones, feeling adventurous. I expected a more-or-less conventional detective story - but as Deany writes in his superb review, that's not exactly what you get. All set to write a review, I logged onto DooYoo... and then found Deany's op.
So rather than try to repeat Deany's content, here my take on it, in acrostic version instead...

Q uestion:
U npick a man,
I solate him from his world: is he
N ullified, a
N amed nonentity?

I s Black White?
S eek the man,

A uster hints,
U nder the trappings.
S earch.
T hink.
E njoy.
R eflect.



Summary:

Last members to rate this review:
(6 members total)

Mauri%2Fkarenuk%2FMALU%2Fcalypte%2Futero%2Fmichaelhudson%2F

View all 6 member ratings

Overall rating: Somewhat useful

Nominate for a Crown:

See all newly Crowned Reviews

Last comments:
annalindsay

- 25/07/03

Ho hum! That'll larn me to experiment...! Ah well, that's how one learns!! :-) Meanwhile, thanks everyone for taking the time to comment... hope any future ops will be back to expectation!
Mauri

- 24/07/03

It really doesn't matter if someone else has written an op on this you should write your own... I hope you do and I'll gladly re rate it, but as Calypte says as a book cat guide I really can't rate this op much higher...sorry :o(

BTW if you like this book you should watch the film 'Smoke' which was partly based on it and for which Paul Auster wrote the screenplay.
MALU

- 24/07/03

What do we learn from that? NEVER read other people's ops before you start writing!!!

View all 5 comments

Top