Welcome! Log in or Register

The Death of Torberta Turchin - Shannon Mawhiney

  • image
1 Review

Genre: Sci-Fi / Fantasy / Author: Shannon Mawhiney / Paperback / 312 Pages / Book is published 2011-03-11 by Createspace

  • Write a review >
    How do you rate the product overall? Rate it out of five by clicking on one of the hearts.
    What are the advantages and disadvantages? Use up to 10 bullet points.
    Write your reviews in your own words. 250 to 500 words
    Number of words:
    Write a concise and readable conclusion. The conclusion is also the title of the review.
    Number of words:
    Write your email adress here Write your email adress

    Your dooyooMiles Miles

    1 Review
    Sort by:
    • More +
      23.09.2011 20:59
      Very helpful
      (Rating)

      Advantages

      Disadvantages

      Recommended

      Torberta (aka Torby) is a 14 year-old orphan who lost her parents in a car accident and since then she acquired a special skill: she can hear and talk to dead people, but she cannot see them. Her relatives find her strange and spooky, and believe that she is mentally unstable, so they enrol her at St Christopher's Academy, a boarding school for kids and teenagers with mental problems and learning difficulties, and they try to keep their contact with her to a minimum. Torberta prefers staying at school anyway, as she has a few friends there and she feels safe. She can also communicate with the ghost of a young man named Charlie, who has become kind of her guardian angel. The problem is that other ghosts try to communicate with her as well, most of the time for their own selfish reasons, making Torby's life miserable.

      On her website, the author explains that after many failed attempts to find an agent, she decided to self-publish the book, initially on Amazon's Kindle and later on paper. This review regards the printed version of the book and I don't believe that because it is a self-published book it is deprived in literary quality. The book aims primarily at young adults, but I found it suitable for older teenagers and older adults as well.

      It is essentially a well-written, bitter-sweet story about what could be an average teenager who feels insecure, lonely and abandoned. Torby feels rejected by her relatives, but even more so by her own dead parents, as she tries to understand whether they have "moved on" after their deaths, and why they never tried to communicate with her since she has that special gift. Sometimes, she also doubts her own sanity.

      The language and dialogues flow very well, and the story is well-written. The description of the boarding school brings to the readers' minds memories of their own school years with the favourite and boring teachers, the nice kids and the bullies. It feels like a combination of The Sixth Sense and Harry Potter.

      However, it is unfortunate that the author reveals Torby's fate on the back cover summary. There is absolutely no need for that direct revelation - the title could be considered ambiguous or just a game of impressions - as it makes the story more predictable. In addition, until around page 160, the story is mostly a description of Torby's everyday life at the Academy and at her relatives' house. It's only after chapter 14 (out of 24) that new characters and some mystery and action are introduced. If there were some hints that things went wrong here and there in the earlier chapters, the story would be more balanced and more enjoyable.

      The font size is adequate for easy reading, wit lots of space between paragraphs and dialogues. However, if the text alignment were justified and there were indentation at the beginning of each new paragraph or dialogue line, the book would look more professional. In addition, to separate the different sections within chapters, three stars (***) instead of a full line of them would be enough.

      The author gives food for though regarding metaphysics, the paranormal and life after death. It is a pleasant read and I generally recommend it, but maybe not so suitable for the very emotional and fragile teenagers with issues around death and suicide.

      Many thanks to the author and the Fantasy Book Review website (www.fantasybookreview.co.uk) for providing my review copy.

      Mawhiney Shannon, The Death of Torberta Turchin. Charleston: USA, 2011. pp. 307. ISBN 1460937902, ISBN-13 978-1460937907.

      Availability:

      * Amazon.com Kindle Edition $5.74, paperback (new) $11.69
      * Amazon.co.uk Kindle Edition £2.14, paperback (currently only used) from £10.94

      Comments

      Login or register to add comments