When I upgraded my Sky package to digital I had doubts whether the extra Music channels were actually needed. But now I listen to MTV Extra more than MTV itself. I think that its better due to the range of music played whereas on channels like MTV Base they just play a certain type of music (usually Drum 'n' Bass or R 'n' B)

MTV Extra still has the ridiculous amount of adverts that all Sky Channels have but you can't complain really. MTV Extra is my favourite music channel which is pretty good going considering the competition like Kiss, The Box and MTV!