Home > TV > TV Programme >

Reviews for Gormenghast


Steerpike is not the hero, he's a virus -  Gormenghast TV Programme
Gormenghast 

Newest Review: ... a kitchen boy who works his way up the rankings in the weird kingdom that is Gormenghast. Is he the villian or the hero though? Watch... more

Steerpike is not the hero, he's a virus (Gormenghast)

jdkane

Member Name: jdkane

Product:

Gormenghast

Date: 08/03/01 (96 review reads)
Rating:

Advantages: this is, at the base of it, a more conventional tale than the critics would like.

Disadvantages: The look is too chinese - the book feels more english.

A lot of people have talked a lot of rubbish about this adaptation.

The look is too chinese - the book feels more english. Though brilliant, the look is just not right. Peake lived in China, but probably was not influenced to that extent.

Ghormengast is a story of class revolt, and I do not think that Peake was in favour of it. The book shows the steady state of society as being grim and tradition-locked. You don't see the ordinary people; everyone's a gargoyle.

The writer writes [comparatively] obscure fiction for avid readers - and to them, burning a library is about the worst thing imaginable. We must ask ourselves; is Manservant Flay [Christopher Lee] worse than a conniving young murderer?

Steerpike is not the hero, he's a virus - a warning against change for change's sake. Titus is the hero, although volume one ends when he is still only 2 years old! In the end, Titus brings more change than Steerpike ever did! Steerpike is just a conventional man of dark passions. And this is, at the base of it, a more conventional tale than the critics would like.

Summary:

Last members to rate this review:
(8 members total)

elvis42%2Fmpeh%2FSqueakyG%2Fronniec%2Fmo79%2Fsalty_monk%2F

View all 8 member ratings

Overall rating: Useful

Nominate for a Crown:

See all newly Crowned Reviews


Top