Home > TV > TV Programme >

Reviews for Star Trek - Deep Space Nine


SF soap opera -  Star Trek - Deep Space Nine TV Programme
Star Trek - Deep Space Nine 

Newest Review: ... think are all that bad. They live in an idealistic society with no crime, corruption, etc. In there whole history no individual (if yo... more

SF soap opera (Star Trek - Deep Space Nine)

Asylum

Member Name: Asylum

Product:

Star Trek - Deep Space Nine

Date: 05/11/00 (30 review reads)
Rating:

Advantages: interesting technology

Disadvantages: soap opera syndrome

As a strong fan of the original Star Trek series, I naturally took a great interest in each of the successive offerings. In the case of Voyager and The Next Generation I gradually became accustomed to their specific values and learned to appreciate what they had to offer. However, Deep Space 9 is a totally different story.
The early episodes were nothing to go wild about, but the situation and the good cross section of alien culture was very promising, so I expected things to improve.
Sadly, things did anything but improve. In an attempt to generate interesting background stories for the characters it gradually fell to the level of a soap opera set in a space station. If the format had remained as a series, this could well have been an excellent program, but now has very little to offer.
I understand that soap operas have a huge support and also that viewing figures are important, but I expect SF to be advertised as such and soaps to be advertised as soaps. This series is a great disappointment and should not carry the title of Star Trek.

Summary:

Last members to rate this review:
(10 members total)

broksababe%2FMattWild%2Fsideards%2FTLC1%2Fronniec%2Fcarolinesite%2F

View all 10 member ratings

Overall rating: Very useful

Nominate for a Crown:

See all newly Crowned Reviews

Last comments:
ronniec

- 05/12/00

It was weak to begin with, and got progressively mediocre as it went on. However I would have rated this higher than SU if you'd gone into the reasons why you dislike it a little... :)
Diaz

- 05/12/00

I think DS9 has a soapy feel because they are trying to run a long story arc along the lines of Babylon 5 as oposed to the episodic STNG.
Whitehorse

- 06/11/00

I mostly agree with you. There is the odd episode that I have really enjoyed and there is a lot of potential. Somehow though, they just don't seem to be able to unleash that potential. It's the only Star Trek programme that I regularly miss - most often because I simply forget!


Top